Skill: course-build → write-lesson (L01 / L03 / L05 facts with one boundary case; L02 / L04 categorical sorts by example sequence; L06 the capstone sort by one question) → write-example-sequence, design-check-sequence, sentence-atomise, write-explanation, write-mcqs (quizzes, practice, PP100 bank and type sheet); write-video-script (intro, six scripts, summary) @ b0fa825

Grade 4 Topic 20 — How rock breaks, moves and settles — build record (v1, 2 October 2026)

What this is, in plain words

Six short lessons, one per atom, for the Grade 4 Earth and Space sequence. A child walks one trail with Miss Ramos's class, from a hilltop boulder down to a lake, and meets the three things that happen to rock along the way. First the boulder on the hilltop: it cracked, and its pieces lie right beside it — nobody smashed it; rock breaks slowly by itself, right where it sits, and that is weathering. Then what did the breaking: a root in a sidewalk slab, ice in a crack, rain, blown sand, hot days and cold nights. Then the morning after rain: the grit beside the boulder is gone — not disappeared, but carried down the slope into the river, and that is erosion. Then what carries: the river's moving water, the wind, a glacier's ice, and Earth's pull (the heap at the foot of the cliff — the river did not put it there; the rocks fell). Then the lake: a flat fan of sand where the river slowed and dropped it, and that is deposition. Last, the whole trail in one picture and the one question that sorts any change: what happened to the rock — did it break where it sits, were its pieces carried away, or were they dropped in a new place?

Three terms are coined (weathering, erosion, deposition) plus "glacier" as a named carrier. All three terms are ten letters, so they are recalled by MCQ, never typed (RECALL_BY_MCQ). Earth's pull is the carrier and "gravity" names the happening, in Grade 3 Topic 3's own sentences.

Counts. 6 lessons · 6 scripts (136, 150, 138, 150, 150, 148 spoken words) + intro (118 words, 2 question marks) + summary (140 words, opener exact) · 6 attached questions + the intro's poll + 3 summary questions (key string in video order A B B A B C A B B, B 5 of 9) · 58 quiz items (10 + 9 + 9 + 11 + 10 + 9... see the per-lesson table) · 12 practice items (9 MCQ, 1 written answer, 3 term recalls by MCQ last; three Grade 3 retrievals first) · PP100 bank 54 items (17 easy · 22 medium · 15 hard; 9 per atom; 3 typed, 1 multi-select, 2 drawn cards; keys A 14 · B 14 · C 11 · D 11) · 59 figures (47 svg, 7 photo placeholders, 5 cartoon placeholders; 12 image briefs). Articles 313 / 360 / 291 / 315 / 326 / 322 words (see "Article length" below).

Structural decisions (in place of a blueprint)

• Lesson order and titles follow the architecture row: L01 "Weathering: rock breaks right where it sits" (EAR4-020) → L02 "What does the breaking" (EAR4-021) → L03 "Erosion: the pieces are carried away" (EAR4-022) → L04 "What carries the pieces" (EAR4-023) → L05 "Deposition: the carrier drops the pieces" (EAR4-024) → L06 "Weathering, erosion or deposition?" (EAR4-025, capstone). Reason: each process is coined before its agents are sorted (what a thing IS before what does it — JM-P1b), and the capstone sort needs all three coined.
• One running scene, six moments: the trail (hilltop boulder → sidewalk slab on the path → the slope after rain → the valley floor by the river → the river's mouth at the lake → the look back). Reason: the three processes happen in sequence along one route, so one trail shows the sequence without a word of extra teaching, and L06's journey map is the same drawing with labels.
• Headache per lesson — each a claim a child would make, put by a named child, answered verdict-first in the next line: L01 "Somebody must have smashed it" (no: it broke slowly by itself, in place); L02 "A root is too soft to break rock" (no: it grew thicker each year and pushed the crack wider); L03 "The pieces disappeared" (no: the rain water carried them down into the river); L04 "The river must have carried those rocks here" (no: the heap is at the cliff's foot, not by the river; the rocks fell — Earth's pull); L05 "The river is still carrying this sand" (no: the sand lies still; the river slowed and dropped it); L06 "Those pieces moved a little when they broke off, so that is erosion" (no: pieces right beside the rock they broke from have not been carried anywhere — the boundary sentence).
• Example sequences, written out.
• L01 (fact, cases then one boundary case; rule and coin last): the hilltop boulder, many winters ago → today (same place, smaller pieces) → the old stone wall (top stones crumbled, chips along its base) → a mountain's rocky top (flakes at its foot) → the table of three → BOUNDARY: pebbles in a stream a mile from any big rock — broken rock, but not where it broke; something carried them (the word waits for L03) → "When rock breaks into smaller pieces right where it sits, we call it weathering."
• L02 (categorical, one frame "<The agent> broke the rock. So <the agent> did the weathering.", no because on the frames, the rule induced after): a root (the slab) → ice (the boulder's crack: the ice took more room than the water did, so it pushed the crack wider) → water (rain wears a dip in a flat rock) → wind (blown sand scrapes a desert rock) → heat and cold (the rock swells a little by day and shrinks a little by night, so flakes come off) → the agents table → rule. No non-example: every case is weathering; the sort is which agent.
• L03 (fact with one near-miss non-example; frame "The <carrier> carried the pieces away."): the grit washed down the slope into the river → dry soil blown off a field to a town miles away → NON-EXAMPLE: a boulder that cracks and keeps its pieces right beside it (weathering: nothing carried them) → the boundary sentence ("If the pieces are still where the rock broke, nothing has carried them. If the pieces are somewhere new, something carried them.") → "When the broken pieces are carried away to somewhere new, we call it erosion." → the weathering-versus-erosion table.
• L04 (categorical, one frame "<The carrier> carried the pieces away. So <the carrier> did the erosion."): Earth's pull (the cliff heap; Grade 3's landslide recalled in its own sentence) → moving water (the river's sand) → wind (sand along a beach; the dune photo) → ice (a glacier, coined as "a river of ice that slides downhill very slowly"; the Alaska photo) → the carriers table → rule.
• L05 (fact with one near miss; frame "The carrier slows down (melts). It drops the pieces."): the river slows at the lake and drops its sand in a flat fan → the wind slows at a bush and drops its sand in a pile → the glacier melts and drops its rocks in a heap → NON-EXAMPLE: sand in a fast river, still inside the water, still moving (erosion: nothing dropped yet) → "When the carried pieces are dropped in a new place, we call it deposition." → the drop table (carrier · what makes it drop · where the pieces end up).
• L06 (capstone sort by one question, frame "The rock <broke where it sits / its pieces were carried away / its pieces were dropped in a new place>. So this is <term>."): the boundary case first (pieces right beside the cracked boulder: weathering, not erosion) → ice widens a crack (W) → flood water rushes soil off a field (E) → mud settles on the inside of a river's bend (D — the register's own example) → a root splits a slab (W) → the sort table → the journey map with its three labels → rule.
• Check types. Type (a) fluency on every lesson (each atom is a one-step sort or a fact true of every case); L06 adds the type (c) tail the capstone owes — a misconception claim, a transfer on a drawn card, a claim about the order of the three. Records below.
• Videos. All six lessons are "video and article". L01 and L03 could do without a video if James wants fewer: each is a fact with one boundary case and the article carries it alone; the scripts are written and batched so he can choose. L02, L04 and L06 need the video: the example sequence on cards is the teaching.
• Figures. Every process card is one shape (Topic 21's two-panel strip with the question above and ONE verdict chip beneath — green BROKE IN PLACE, blue CARRIED AWAY, tan DROPPED HERE); item cards carry no chip and no question. Grade 3's cracked rock and size strip are imported for the recall of EAR3-002; Grade 3's landslide strip for EAR3-009; Topic 18's measured table and step helpers. Real things (a cracked boulder, a crumbling wall, a root-split sidewalk, a sandy river bed, a dune, an Alaska glacier, a sand fan at a lake) are photo placeholders; the class is five cartoon placeholders. Register in content/figures.py.
• Simplifications, named (vault: Name the simplification you made). (1) "The ice took more room than the water did" stands in for expansion on freezing; no reason is given. (2) "The rock swells a little by day and shrinks a little by night" stands in for thermal expansion; the words are literal, not figurative. (3) "A slow river cannot hold its sand up" stands in for the physics of carrying capacity. (4) A glacier is "a river of ice that slides downhill very slowly"; how ice flows is not taught. (5) Grade 3's landslide is named as Earth's pull doing erosion; rain's part in loosening the slope is said in the quiz feedback only.

Questions for James

• Should the pieces lying right beside a cracked boulder count as weathering, not erosion, as taught here? Context: a fallen piece has moved a few inches by Earth's pull, and L04 names Earth's pull as a carrier (the cliff heap). I drew the line at "somewhere new": pieces right beside the rock they broke from are weathering; a heap at the foot of a tall cliff, or a landslide's heap, is erosion by Earth's pull. The boundary sentence is in L03 and L06, and no item sits on a case between the two (no "pieces a few feet down the slope"). Recommendation: keep the line; it matches TEKS 4.10B's and Florida 4.E.6.4's reading of weathering as breaking in place. Built: as described.
• Is "none of these" acceptable as the fourth option of the capstone's sort set? Context: a PP100 MCQ needs four options; the three terms are the only sisters. "None of these" is the KEY in two hard items (melted rock cooling into rock; a rock unchanged in a museum case) and never padding — your Topic 2 ruling allows a "cannot tell / none" option where it is genuinely right. The alternative is a fourth sister word ("a landslide"), which I used in the naming set WED4. Recommendation: keep SORT4 with "none of these"; it also tests that the student can refuse all three. Built: SORT4 on 10 items, WED4 on 5.
• Should L01 and L03 be articles only (no video)? Context above. Recommendation: keep the videos — the headache claim answered aloud over the drawing is the one teaching moment each. Built: both.

What each lesson teaches

design-check-sequence records

`

Skill: design-check-sequence @ b0fa825

Part: L01 (whole lesson)

Type: (a) — the student says whether a described change is rock breaking in place; one label, yes or no.

Plan: 1 Grade 3 recall (two options) → 6 yes / no cases (string y y n y n y n — two near misses: carried pebbles, a boulder rolling whole) → 1 term recognition (weathering / melting / rotting) → 2 claims (no, no). Stems one sentence plus the ask.

Belongs in practice/test instead: the four-option naming item (WED4), the where-are-the-pieces item.

Part: L02 (whole lesson)

Type: (a) — the student places a described case under one of five agents.

Plan: 8 case → agent items, four options each drawn from the five (three option sets so no position is learnable; key string 1 3 0 2 1 1 3 0) → 1 claim (water is too soft to break rock — no). Belongs elsewhere: pick-the-case-for-a-named-agent (bank type 5 reversed), the mechanism items (bank type 8).

Part: L03 (whole lesson)

Type: (a) — weathering or erosion, one label per case.

Plan: 6 two-option sorts (string n y n y y y, two near misses: halves stay; flakes along the wall) → 1 term recognition (erosion / weathering) → 2 claims (one thing — no; disappeared — no). Belongs elsewhere: the four-way sort with deposition (bank type 6).

Part: L04 (whole lesson)

Type: (a) — the student places a described case under one of four carriers.

Plan: 1 Grade 3 recall (Earth's pull, three options) → 7 case → carrier on the fixed set CARRIER4 (key string 3 0 1 2 3 0 2) → 1 TRUE claim (Earth pulled the rocks down — yes) → 1 false claim (ice does not move — no) → glacier recognition last. Belongs elsewhere: the typed carrier (bank type 9), the fixed-wrong-claim reason items (bank type 4).

Part: L05 (whole lesson)

Type: (a) — erosion or deposition, and the one cause of dropping.

Plan: 5 two-option sorts (string n y y n y, two near misses: pebbles still rolling; sand still flying) → 3 what-made-it-drop items (three options; keys 0 1 2) → 1 term recognition (deposition / erosion / weathering) → 1 claim (fast water drops the most — no). Belongs elsewhere: the prediction of where the carrier drops (bank type 8 hard), the typed cause (bank type 9).

Part: L06 (whole lesson)

Type: (a) on the three-way sort, then the (c) tail the capstone owes.

Plan: 7 three-option sorts (string 2 0 1 2 1 0 2; two boundary cases: flakes at the rock's base; a piece right next to the rock) → misconception claim (erosion is the breaking — no) → transfer on a drawn card (the stone marker, a fresh scene; the card carries no chip) → order claim (dropped before carried — no). Belongs elsewhere: the four-way sort with none of these (bank type 6), the multi-select (bank type 10).

`

The key strings

• Lesson quizzes: L01 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 1 1 (two-option y y y n y n y n n; three-option 0) · L02 1 3 0 2 1 1 3 0 1 (four-option 1 3 0 2 1 1 3 0, no position over 3 of 8; two-option n) · L03 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 (two-option n y n y y y y n n — 5 of 9 at the first position after the reorder, no four in a row alternating) · L04 0 3 0 1 2 3 0 2 0 1 1 (four-option 3 0 1 2 3 0 2; three-option 0 1; two-option y n) · L05 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 2 0 1 (two-option n y y n y n; three-option 0 1 2 0) · L06 2 0 1 2 1 0 2 1 0 1 (three-option 2 0 1 2 1 0 2 0; two-option n n).
• Attached questions in video order (lessons, then summary; the intro's poll has no key): A B B A B C A B B — B 5 of 9 (56 %).
• Practice: 0 1 2 0 0 1 1 2 – 0 1 2 (the FRQ has no key).
• PP100: A 14 · B 14 · C 11 · D 11 over 50 single-key MCQs; the multi-select's set is A and C; three typed items.

The 2 October rules, applied

Misconceptions confronted (the catalogue is silent on weathering, erosion and deposition; sources named)

Checker: 0 FAIL, 72 WARN (python3 build_tools_check_topic.py grade4/topic20_build/content/G4T20.py)

• S8 "beat carries N sentences" (×28) — kept: the Grade 3-5 micro-lesson beats are short multi-sentence paragraphs (write-video-script's continuous-speech layout); every script is ≤ 150 words (S25 passes).
• S10 scene-word reuse (×10 after the re-scene pass) — kept, each read: "crack" (L02 ×6) is the topic's working noun for every weathering-by-ice-or-root case and is in no sense a scene; "boulder" (L01 q6: a boulder rolling whole, the near miss — the noun is the point); "beside" (L02 q2, a pine tree beside a wall); "river" (L04 q7, grains down a river to the sea — the carrier class needs a water body). No quiz item restages a lesson scene.
• S36 unusual words (41) — answered one by one: kept boulder/boulders (Grade 3 Topic 26's word, on its size strip chip), trail (the plain US word for a park path), grit (Grade 3 Topic 26's word), halves, smashed, split/splitting, sped, shrink/shrinks/shrank (the plain words for getting smaller), disappear/disappeared (everyday), dandelion, curb, ledge, slab (glossed "a concrete sidewalk slab"), concrete, statue, dune (caption only, "a sand dune"), prairie, beaver, gutter, marsh, patio, museum, event, gusts/gusty (grade-4 words; "gusts" is the deliberate clue in the typed wind item), groove, infield, bleachers, volleyball, construction, scattered, beyond, burnt, plateau ("a bare plateau in Arizona"), culvert (glossed "a big pipe under the road"), chunk (one bank stem, "a chunk of ice"); swapped creek → stream (James: say river; "stream" is on the familiar list), hollow → dip (James: say what is empty), chunk → piece in the summary and L04 quiz, bluff → cliff / rock slope, cove → beach, ridges → bumps, ridge → heap, slabs → pieces, rarely → hardly ever, usual → the gusts always hit, vanished/vanish/exists → disappeared/disappear/is still somewhere.
• S13 key text in stem — cleared: the two "wind" stems were reworded ("blown sand", "the gusts").
• S7 key balance — cleared for L03, L05 and the bank after reorders (strings above).
• S34 glacier — cleared: a recognition MCQ was added as L04's last item.
• S4 long stem — cleared: the Minnesota boulder stem cut to two sentences.
• S29 units 0 · S37 strand 0 · S39 size words 0 · S35 typed_long 0 · S30 typed 3, fail 0, warn 0 (PP-41 and PP-42 are closed by the author's note, which S30 prints as INFO).

python3 grade4/check_g4_articles.py … → 0 FAIL (scripts 136 / 150 / 138 / 150 / 150 / 148; intro 118; summary 140, opener ok).

python3 build_tools_build_topic_site.py … /tmp/g4t20.html → 6 lessons, 12 practice, 54 pp100, 59 figures. Page opened: header, blurb, intro script, poll and lesson list render.

python3 build_tools_blind_bundle.py … blind/2026-10-02 → 129 mcq, 3 text, 1 frq, 1 multi, 134 held; key file sequestered.

python3 build_tools_video_batch.py … → 8 videos; check_brief.py → 7 ✓, INTRO's one standing R79 hit (accepted, every intro); grep -ci strand → 0. Not sent.

python3 build_tools_names.py Ramos Jenna Jesse Joel → all four free, exit 0.

Article length (the Grade 4 brief: 170–300, WARN above 300 acceptable with a subtitle or figure every ≤ 8 lines and a reason)

L01 313 (25 idea lines, 8 figures, 4 subtitles), L02 360 (25 lines, 8 figures, 4 subtitles), L03 291, L04 315 (22 lines, 10 figures, 4 subtitles), L05 326 (23 lines, 8 figures, 5 subtitles), L06 322 (22 lines, 9 figures, 4 subtitles). No stretch runs more than 5 idea lines without a figure or subtitle. Reason for the length: each article re-states its headache scene so it stands alone without the video, carries a Grade 3 recall sentence word for word, and runs a full example sequence (L02 has five agents, L04 four carriers — the atoms are categorical with that many classes). Grade 3's approved articles have a median of 308 words. L02 at 360 is the longest; a split would put the check between the agents and break the sequence. Flagged, not trimmed further.

Bank freshness, re-performed

Scene nouns of every lesson, quiz, attached and summary item (boulder, sidewalk slab, root, statue, dandelion, parking lot, stone roof, stone step, garden-wall brick, stone wall, cliff, hilltop, lake, sand fan, bush, glacier, Alaska, Minnesota, canyon, farm, Canada, meadow, ditch, trees, waves, bay, stone marker, river bend, flood, pond, fence, dune, mountain top, desert, heap, harbor, bridge, gravel, snow…) were grepped against the bank and the practice set. First pass found 24 shared nouns and eleven real scene reuses (brick chimney ↔ garden-wall brick; fort wall ↔ stone wall; sea-cliff flakes ↔ cliff flakes; hilltop cracked rock ↔ L01's headache; pine root in a stone wall ↔ stone fountain; mountain-top heat and cold ↔ L02's case; gravel road to a ditch ↔ snow-melt gravel to a ditch; dust storm off farms ↔ L03's dusty field; Montana rocks in ice ↔ Alaska rocks in ice; Montana glacier-end boulders ↔ Canada ice boulders; glacier-end heap typed item ↔ L05 quiz q4; cliff heap carried-by-a-river claim ↔ L04's headache; flood gravel to a meadow ↔ L06's meadow; river mud at a lake ↔ L05's headache; the mountain-top item card ↔ L02's card). Every one was re-scened (lighthouse top; sea-cave roof; rock face above a road; pasture rock; stone fountain; Nevada hillside; sandbox across a schoolyard; burnt forest floor; scratched valley floor; Ohio field rocks; iceberg stones on the sea floor; mud on a flooded street in July; melt water down a ski slope to a golf course; mud on a valley floor; the concrete planter card). Second grep: the only shared nouns are class words the topic cannot avoid (rock, sand, mud, soil, river, stream, valley, hill, road, street, wall) plus "statue" (a DISTRACTOR option in PP-17, not a scene), "bridge" (a different move), "waves" (agent water, not a carrier case), "glacier" (the only ice carrier the grade knows — four bank items, each a new scene), "cliff" (PP-47's drawn card: the same scene KIND as L04's headache, rockfall, but the capstone sort rather than the carrier — recorded in the type sheet's inventory and ⟂ list). Print of the second grep: SHARED NOUNS: boulder L43/B7/P0; statue L1/B1/P0; stone wall L5/B0/P1; cliff L17/B2/P0; hilltop L9/B1/P0; lake L16/B3/P0; glacier L10/B4/P0; farm L1/B1/P0; waves L1/B2/P1; flood L3/B5/P0; fence L1/B0/P1; desert L6/B2/P0; bridge L2/B2/P0; gravel L3/B8/P1; … (generic class words follow).

Figures (59; author's review-figures self-check on every render)

All 59 SVGs were rendered through headless Chrome to ten contact sheets and opened; every PNG was looked at. Fixes made on the renders before hand-over: six drawers spilled outside their panel (the glacier, the glacier-drop slope, the cliff, the river-lake, the hill slope, the wind streaks) — all shrunk to the panel; two labels overflowed ("THE ICE SLIDES DOWNHILL, A LITTLE EACH YEAR", "THE SAME SAND, FARTHER DOWN THE RIVER", "THE SAME MARKER, 100 YEARS LATER") — shortened; the glacier card's after panel was identical to its before — the tongue now draws farther down; rule cards' last line crossed the card's bottom border — card height increased; the journey map had a white gap between sky and ground and its weathering chip ran off the left edge — fixed; the river card's grains floated above the water — grains now sit inside the band. After the fixes the twelve changed figures were re-rendered and opened. One depiction per thing: Grade 3's stone glyph for every rock; Topic 21's panel and arrow for every card; Topic 18's table and sand / mud / pebble colours; Grade 3's cracked rock and size strip imported for the Grade 3 recall; Grade 3's landslide strip imported. Item figures: q_card_gravestone (L06 transfer), pr_card_dune_fence (practice), pp_card_planter and pp_card_cliff_heap (bank); each carries blind= data that names only what is drawn.

Sentence-atomise self-check (per lesson; the mechanical twin S1 / S2 / S38 is clean)

Every "why" is three lines, fact → application → "So …"; every fb ≤ 30 words (S5 clean); no figurative verb (the ice "pushes", the rock "swells a little", the river "drops").

Judgement calls, recorded

1. Pieces beside the rock are weathering — see Questions for James. The line is drawn at "somewhere new".
2. "None of these" in the sort set — see Questions for James; the two keyed cases are a change to rock that is none of the three (lava cooling) and no change at all.
3. Typed items produce agents and causes, not the terms — the three terms are ten-letter words (James, 30 Sep: an MCQ for a word the grade cannot spell); the hard tier is therefore mostly well-made MCQs (nine), plus wind / melted / slowed typed and one multi-select. Three typed items is below the MS target of twelve to eighteen; the Grade 4 brief allows "a well-made MCQ" as a hard form.
4. Earth's pull as a carrier — Florida 4.E.6.4 names gravity; the lesson says "Earth's pull" throughout and quotes Grade 3's "Earth's pull is called gravity." once. A rockfall and a landslide are the cases; L04's quiz feedback says rain loosened the landslide's soil so no child reads "rain carried it".
5. The jar of Topic 18 is not re-drawn: Topic 18's running scene (Miss Lopez's jar) belongs to that topic; L05 recalls its step-card sentence "Small pieces settle in a layer." only. Topic 18's text module did not yet exist on disk when this topic was written (only its figures.py), so the sentence is quoted from its figure caption; if Topic 18's lexicon words it differently, L05's one recall line should follow it.
6. Glacier coined as a fourth term because "ice" alone cannot carry rock in a child's picture; the coin is in L04 and recalled by MCQ.
7. Article lengths above 300 on five of six — kept with the reason above; L02 is flagged as the one a reviewer might split.
8. S36 "gusts" kept as the deliberate clue in the typed wind item (the stem cannot say "wind").
9. "creek" never appears: James's standing note on the word; every creek became a stream.
10. The summary speaks all six rule sentences (140 words), not four: the two agent lists are the atoms EAR4-021 and 023 and would be lost if folded.

Owed

• Blind review of the bundle (blind/2026-10-02/BLIND_BUNDLE_G4T20.md; keys sequestered) by two cold readers; review-questions and review-figures passes by a non-author; review-accuracy on the five agents and four carriers.
• The video batch is built and checked, not sent (handoff/G4T20/videos/READY.md); James's review of the scripts is the cue.
• The picture pass (7 photos, 5 cartoons) waits for James's sign-off on the three questions above (the standing sequencing rule).
• Nothing committed.

v2 — reviews applied (2 October 2026)

Skill: course-build → write-lesson (the L02 split and every article line) → write-video-script (the trimmed script beats) → write-mcqs (every item change) → write-explanation (fb / why / model lines) → sentence-atomise (every new sentence) @ 3a2c39d. Applies, in this order of authority, BLIND_READ_G4T20_2026-10-02.md, REVIEW_G4T20_2026-10-02.md, FIGURES_REVIEW_G4T20_2026-10-02.md. Nothing under grade3/ or another topic's folder was touched. Nothing committed.

In plain words. The topic had one contradiction a child would meet: flakes in a heap at a cliff's foot were keyed weathering in one place and rocks at a cliff's foot were keyed erosion in another. The line is now drawn in words, once, in L04, and every item follows it: pieces that lie right beside the rock they broke from have not been carried (weathering); pieces that fall or roll away from it, down to somewhere new, have been carried by Earth's pull (erosion). The five-agent lesson is now two short lessons with a two-option check between them (roots and ice push a crack wider · water, wind, heat and cold wear the rock away), so the topic has seven lessons. Rain no longer wears rock anywhere (that is the chemical case the atom bars); running water does. The running scene keeps one dataset: after the rain the grit is gone and the big pieces are still beside the boulder, and L07's headache points at those big pieces.

Finding → change

Questions for James — built as recommended

1. The line stays at "somewhere new" (TEKS 4.10B, Florida 4.E.6.4) — and is now written once, in L04, with the Earth's-pull half named in L05. 2. "None of these" stays in the sort set, keyed in PP-48 and PP-49, ⟂ so never two per test. 3. The videos stay (nine, the two halves of L02 each with their own).

The new lesson list and counts

L01 Weathering: rock breaks right where it sits (EAR4-020; 317 words, 136 spoken, 10 items) · L02 What does the breaking: roots and ice push the crack wider (EAR4-021; 214 / 139 / 8) · L03 What does the breaking: water, wind, heat and cold wear the rock away (EAR4-021; 282 / 139 / 9) · L04 Erosion: the pieces are carried away (EAR4-022; 313 / 136 / 10, one drawn transfer) · L05 What carries the pieces (EAR4-023; 353 / 145 / 11) · L06 Deposition: the carrier drops the pieces (EAR4-024; 335 / 146 / 10) · L07 Weathering, erosion or deposition? (EAR4-025; 324 / 145 / 10). Intro 118 words; summary 155 (opener exact; seven lessons' rules). 68 quiz items + 7 attached + 3 summary + 12 practice; bank 54 (17 · 22 · 15; per atom 9 · 9 · 8 · 10 · 9 · 9; tags rising within every tier). 60 figures (46 svg, 7 photo, 6 cartoon; 13 briefs). Articles over 300 (L01, L04–L07) keep a figure or subtitle every ≤ 8 lines, as v1 recorded.

Key strings

Quizzes: L01 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 1 1 · L02 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 · L03 0 0 2 1 0 3 2 0 1 · L04 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 1 1 · L05 0 3 0 1 1 2 3 0 2 0 1 · L06 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 2 0 1 · L07 2 0 1 2 1 0 2 1 0 1. Attached in video order: A B A B A B C A B B (B 5 of 10). Practice 0 1 2 0 0 1 1 2 – 0 1 2. Bank A 11 · B 14 · C 12 · D 13 over 50 single-key MCQs; no key the one long option.

Checker results

build_tools_check_topic.py → 0 FAIL, 88 WARN (S36 words as v1 answered them, plus groove / vines / canal / quarry / ridge kept as the plain names of the things; S10 "crack" ×9 in L02 — the topic's working noun; S10 "smooth" ×3 in L03 — the groove's adjective, not a scene; S13 "water" in two L03 stems — the stem must say the water is running; S22 PP-8 negative-over-negative — a claim item, kept). grade4/check_g4_articles.py → 0 FAIL (article / script: L01 317 / 136 · L02 214 / 143 · L03 282 / 143 · L04 313 / 141 · L05 353 / 149 · L06 335 / 150 · L07 324 / 149; intro 118; summary 155). build_tools_names.py Ramos Jenna Jesse Joel → all free, exit 0. build_tools_build_topic_site.py … /tmp/g4t20_v2.html → 7 lessons, 12 practice, 54 pp100, 60 figures; each lesson's article route screenshotted at 900 px and read (placeholders, cards and tables render; L01's headache card now at the strips' scale). check_svg_ids.py → PASS (60 figures, 0 ids). build_tools_video_batch.py → 9 videos (intro, L01–L07, summary), check_brief.py 8 ✓ + the intro's standing R79 line; grep -ci strand → 0; not sent. Figures re-rendered to /tmp/g4t20_figs/ (four contact sheets of the 32 changed figures and the melt-trickle card opened and read). Fresh bundle blind/2026-10-02-v2 → 139 mcq, 3 text, 1 frq, 1 multi, 144 held; its five [Drawing: lines grepped for weathering|erosion|deposition|breaks|carries|drops|settles|beside|same spot → 0 hits (the gravestone says "to the left and to the right of its base", the planter "at the foot of that side", the cliff "on the ground at its foot", the stream pebbles "resting on its bottom", the fence "just before the posts").

Sentence-atomise, new sentences

Items whose stem, options, key, model, figure, blind text or accept list changed

Lessons: L01 q5; L02 (new lesson) attached + q1–q8; L03 (new lesson) attached + q1–q9; L04 q7 (new drawn transfer) and q10 (vanished), q8 source line; L05 q4 ↔ q5 order, q7 fb/why; L07 q9 fb/why. Bank (new numbering): PP-1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 12, 14, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 29, 30, 31, 33, 34, 36, 39 (moved, retagged), 40 (accept), 41 (new carrier card), 42 (accept), 43 (accept), 45, 47 (stem, blind), 50, 51, 52, 53. Figures changed: boulder_headache, boulder_strip, card_wall, weathering_table, card_roots, card_ice (alt), card_heat_cold, card_wind, card_water, push_table (new), rule_push (new), stream_cartoon (new), agents_table, rain_cartoon, erosion_strip, card_dust, card_stays, card_river, card_wind_carry, card_glacier (alt), card_cliff, deposition_strip, card_wind_drop, card_glacier_drop, card_still_carried, journey_map_headache, journey_map_labels, sort_root_slab, sort_pieces_beside, q_card_gravestone, q_card_stream_pebbles (renamed, fixed), pr_card_dune_fence, pp_card_planter, pp_card_cliff_heap; deleted size_strip_recall, q_card_sandbar; every brief.

v3 — polish (2 October 2026)

Skill: course-build → write-mcqs (the new item, the two re-scenes, the key trims, the PP-9 distractor) → write-explanation (the new fb and why lines) → sentence-atomise (every new sentence) @ efd8fba. Applies the "v2 re-read" section of BLIND_READ_G4T20_2026-10-02.md (Reader C). Nothing committed.

In plain words. The word "landslide" was taught in L05's text but no quiz item asked for it, and a practice item keyed on it. L05's quiz now opens with a naming item in the lesson's own words (a slope of soaked soil and rock slides down all at once → a landslide), placed before the first item whose feedback uses the word. Two quiz items that were lesson scenes with a word changed are fresh scenes now. Two bank keys were trimmed so no key is the longest option, and one bank item's silliest distractor is a real belief.

Key strings after the pass. L05 quiz 0 2 3 0 1 1 2 3 0 2 0 1 (three-option keys 0 2 1; four-option string 3 0 1 2 3 0 2 unchanged; two-option y n). L04 and L07 keys unchanged (re-scenes only). Bank letters unchanged: A 11 · B 14 · C 12 · D 13 (PP-9's key stays at B).

Counts. 69 quiz items (L05 now 12) + 7 attached + 3 summary + 12 practice; bank 54 (17 · 22 · 15; 9 · 9 · 8 · 10 · 9 · 9). Figures 60, unchanged.

Checks. build_tools_check_topic.py → 0 FAIL, 88 WARN (all v2's, none on the changed items; flagpole / picnic / railroad / heavy raise no S36 line). grade4/check_g4_articles.py → 0 FAIL (articles and scripts unchanged). build_tools_build_topic_site.py … /tmp/g4t20_v3.html → 7 lessons, 12 practice, 54 pp100, 60 figures. check_svg_ids.py → PASS (60 figures, 0 ids). Fresh bundle blind/2026-10-02-v3 → 140 mcq, 3 text, 1 frq, 1 multi, 145 held; keys sequestered. Scene words grepped against every content file before use: flagpole, picnic, railroad and "too heavy" appear nowhere else in the topic.

Sentence-atomise, new sentences. Longest new line 20 words ("After a wet week, a slope of soaked soil and rock above a railroad track slides down all at once."); one idea per sentence; every sentence names its actor (the slope, the soaked soil and rock, the stone base, the halves, the ice, the piece, flood water, the rock); cause before effect ("Ice in a crack splits a piece off … and the piece lies on the ground right next to the table"); every fb ≤ 30 words, every why ≤ 50.

Changed ids. Lessons: L04 q2 (stem, fb, why); L05 q2 (new) and q3–q12 (renumbered, text unchanged); L07 q6 (stem, fb, why). Bank: PP-9 (option A, why); PP-20 (key text); PP-34 (key text). Records: TYPES_G4T20.md (a v3 note; the PP-20 ⟂ line's wording; no exemplar changed).

Skill: course-build → review-lesson (Roles B, B2) → review-questions → review-accuracy (non-author pass; filed by the coordinator from the reviewer's hand-back) @ 3a2c39d

Topic 20 — guidance, questions and accuracy review, 2 October 2026

The topic is well built and mostly honest, but it ships one contradiction a blind reader will catch (both did): the course keys "a heap of flakes at the foot of a cliff" as weathering (L01 q5, PP-7) and "rocks at the foot of a cliff" as erosion by Earth's pull (L04 headache, L04 q9, PP-28, PP-47). The author's own answer to question 1 draws the line at "somewhere new"; two items break it. Fix those two and the boundary holds everywhere. Beyond that: the water-weathering case leans on raindrops (not honest as physical weathering); the freshness claim is partly false (five renamed templates); half the bank's keys are the longest option; the Topic 18 quote does not match Topic 18's text. Re-performed and true: 0 FAIL; counts as recorded; 54 items, 9 per atom, tiers rising; keys A 14 B 14 C 11 D 11; "gravity" once, as Grade 3's sentence, never a force; no figurative verb; blind lines data only; every misconception row has its lesson line and item.

The author's three questions, the reviewer's view: (1) keep the line at "somewhere new" (TEKS 4.10B's and Florida 4.E.6.4's reading) — once rows 1 and 2 are fixed; (2) keep "none of these" (both keyed cases are honest non-cases; the ⟂ pair stops two per test); (3) keep the videos.

Skill: course-build → review-figures (non-author pass; filed by the coordinator from the reviewer's hand-back) @ 3a2c39d — figures at g3-5-science commit e9809bd

Topic 20 — figure review, 2 October 2026

The before → after cards read at a glance: one boulder, then the same boulder cracked with pieces beside it. Two things jar: on the trail map and the erosion strip the boulder's crack stabs out of the rock into the soil, and every "what did the breaking / carrying" chip in L02 and L04 is the same tan as DROPPED HERE: DEPOSITION. Page pass PASS (every lesson, quiz, practice, summary and PP100 route opened; every figure renders as it did alone; check_svg_ids.py PASS). Mechanical pass clean.

1. Chip colour (L02 ×5, L04 ×4). wed_card picks the fill by prefix (BROKE / CARRIED), so "ICE DID THE BREAKING", "MOVING WATER CARRIED THE PIECES" fall to tan, the deposition colour L05 coins; the L04 alts say "A blue chip". Match "CARRIED" anywhere → blue; agent chips green or neutral.
2. Crack not scaled to the boulder. boulder() draws a fixed crack path; at r=20 (erosion_strip, journey_map ×2) it runs out of the boulder's base into the soil. Scale the path by r.
3. card_roots / sort_root_slab, after panel. The crack floats in the air above the slab; the slab is not tilted; the root crosses the slab and pokes out beneath. A tilted slab polygon, the crack inside it, the root ending in the joint.
4. card_cliff / pp_card_cliff_heap. The cliff reaches into the label band and the chip half-hides a stone; no ledge drawn; the bank card is L04's teaching card relabelled. Shorten the cliff, draw a ledge step, and give the bank card a fresh instance (cliff on the right, two stones, lower ledge).
5. q_card_gravestone. The grit sits on the marker's own face, not on the ground at its base — the L06 transfer item rests on seeing pieces beside the rock. Spread the grit to either side.
6. card_glacier_drop, after. A grey arc floats mid-slope depicting nothing. Delete, or make it a melt trickle into the puddle.
7. deposition_strip (and q_card_sandbar). The "flat fan" is a dome 24 of the lake's 60 units tall. Flatten to ≤ 8 so caption and alt are true.

Unplaced (5): boulder_photo — PLACE in L01 under the headache; sidewalk_photo — PLACE in L02 beside the cartoon; size_strip_recall — DELETE; q_card_creek_pebbles — DELETE or fix (pebbles perch on the water band) and use as an L03 quiz card; q_card_sandbar — DELETE (the teaching strip relabelled).

Minor: boulders on no ground band (register says ground band); grit glyph reads as arrowheads; card_water grit in the hollow vs alt "beside"; card_heat_cold flakes hover; erosion_strip grey grit becomes tan grains; river and wind cards carry no direction mark; card_river before-chip wider than its panel; boulder_headache renders at ~2.5× the strips' scale; journey_map erosion pointer ends above the slope; blind text for pp_card_planter / q_card_gravestone says "right beside it" / "in the same spot" — the lesson's deciding phrase; say where the bits are and stop; briefs lack "the eye must see" on most and say "plain background" for landscapes. Imports (Grade 3 Topic 26 cracked rock and size strip, Topic 24 landslide, Topic 18 table and placeholders, Topic 21 panels) appear as their sources drew them.

Three best: card_ice, card_dust, journey_map_labels (once the crack is fixed). Three weakest: card_roots, card_cliff / pp_card_cliff_heap, q_card_creek_pebbles.

Skill: course-build → review-lesson (Role A blind key read, two readers; Role C adjudication by the coordinator) @ 3a2c39d

Topic 20 — How rock breaks, moves and settles — blind read, 2 October 2026

Every key agreed by two blind readers (134 items each; MCQ disagreements 0; PP-54 multi B, C matched; the three typed answers on the lists; the FRQ model in the key's words), and the three sorting words plus "glacier" each have a naming item before later quizzes use them. Two bank items have two defensible answers by the topic's own boundary and both readers caught them. The intro poll is not bundled by design.

Flags carried into the fix pass

Readers' files: blind/2026-10-02/READER_A.md, READER_B.md.

v2 re-read, 2 October 2026 (Reader C on blind/2026-10-02-v2, the whole bundle, seven lessons)

Every key agreed (144 items; MCQ disagreements 0; PP-54 multi A, D matched; the three typed words on the lists; the FRQ model in the key's words). The boundary test passed: every sort item gives the place, and beside-the-rock cases resolve to weathering, far-below cases to Earth's pull, slowed or melted carriers to deposition. One flag to the polish pass: "landslide" is never defined by a lesson ITEM (it is in the L05 lesson text, seven mentions) yet is the key of PR-03 — add a recognition item in L05's quiz, or re-key PR-03. Soft: L04-02 and L07-06 are lesson scenes renamed; L05-02 / PP-31 lean on the lesson's landslide line (present); PP-20 / PP-34 mild length tell; PP-09's three absurd distractors. Reader's file: READER_C.md.